What Pickleball Paddle Should I Buy

What Pickleball Paddle Should I Buy: Expert Guide 2025

by

Buy a paddle that fits your skill, swing speed, and style, not hype.

Choosing what pickleball paddle should i buy can feel messy. I test paddles weekly with beginners and 5.0 players. In this guide, I break down specs, budget, and play styles in plain English. You will know what matters, what to skip, and how to pick with confidence. Stick with me, and what pickleball paddle should i buy will be an easy call.

Start with your goal and skill level
Source: networldsports

Start with your goal and skill level

Your goal guides every choice. The right paddle makes good habits easier. The wrong one hides flaws and strains your arm.

  • If you are new, pick control first. It speeds learning.
  • If you are improving, add spin and stability. Keep control.
  • If you compete, match paddle to your plan. Power, spin, or touch.

How I coach it on court:

  • If you pop ups at the net, pick a softer, thicker core.
  • If you leave returns short, add weight or a power face.
  • If your wrist is tired fast, choose midweight and low swing weight.

Ask yourself what pickleball paddle should i buy for my current game, not my dream game. You can always upgrade later.

The specs that matter (and why)
Source: lemonpickleball

The specs that matter (and why)

A paddle is a set of trade-offs. Learn the dials you can turn.

  • Weight

    • Light: 7.2–7.6 oz. Faster hands. Less power. Can be twitchy.
    • Mid: 7.7–8.3 oz. Best blend for most players.
    • Heavy: 8.4–9.0 oz+. More power and stability. Slower hands.

  • Thickness and core

    • 13–14 mm cores feel firmer. More pop. Less dwell.
    • 16–20 mm cores feel softer. More control and forgiveness.
    • Honeycomb polymer is standard. It is arm friendly and quiet.

  • Face material

    • Raw carbon fiber grabs the ball for spin and control.
    • Fiberglass gives easy pop and a lively feel.
    • Hybrid faces mix both. Balanced spin and pop.

  • Shape and size

    • Elongated paddles add reach and serve power.
    • Standard shapes have bigger sweet spots and easy defense.
    • USAP rules cap length at 17 inches and size at 24 total inches.

  • Balance and swing weight

    • Head-light turns fast at the net.
    • Head-heavy hits heavier balls but can tire your arm.
    • Swing weight is how heavy it feels in motion. Try before you buy.

  • Grip size and handle

    • Small grips (about 4.0–4.125 in) help spin and reach.
    • Larger grips (about 4.25–4.5 in) add stability and comfort.
    • Longer handles help two-handed backhands.

  • Build style

    • Thermoformed paddles are stiff and powerful. Big spin. Can be harsh.
    • Traditional builds are softer and more arm friendly.

These specs answer what pickleball paddle should i buy without guesswork.

Match your paddle to your play style and body
Source: pickleballcentral

Match your paddle to your play style and body

Pick the tool for the job. Then your body will thank you.

  • Control-first players

    • Choose 16 mm core, raw carbon face, midweight.
    • Standard shape for a bigger sweet spot.

  • Power servers and bangers

    • Choose 13–14 mm core, thermoformed build, or fiberglass face.
    • Elongated shape for reach and drive speed.

  • Spin-focused players

    • Raw carbon face is your best friend.
    • Add a touch of head weight for deeper bites.

  • Two-handed backhand users

    • Longer handle, at least 5.5 inches.
    • Midweight to keep balance.

  • Elbow or wrist pain

    • Softer 16 mm core, head-light balance, midweight.
    • Add a cushion overgrip. Avoid very stiff builds.

Ask again, with your style in mind: what pickleball paddle should i buy today to win more points next week?

Budget tiers: what you get for your money
Source: lemonpickleball

Budget tiers: what you get for your money

Price does not equal wins. It buys materials and feel. Here is what to expect.

  • Under 75 dollars

    • Great for a first week or family play.
    • Limited spin. Small sweet spot. Fine for learning basics.

  • 75 to 120 dollars

    • Entry raw carbon and better cores show up.
    • Good control and a taste of real spin.

  • 120 to 180 dollars

    • Strong value tier. Many players can stop here.
    • Consistent spin, solid feel, decent durability.

  • 180 to 260 dollars

    • Premium faces, better QC, thermoformed options.
    • High spin, bigger sweet spots, more stable blocks.

  • 260 dollars and up

    • Flagship builds, pro lines, unique tech.
    • Diminishing returns but top feel and finish.

Brands to explore include Selkirk, JOOLA, Paddletek, Engage, CRBN, Six Zero, Vatic Pro, Onix, Gearbox, and Head. What pickleball paddle should i buy on a budget? The 120 to 180 tier is the sweet spot for many.

Fit and comfort: grip, weight, and balance
Source: youtube

Fit and comfort: grip, weight, and balance

Fit beats flash. A well-fit paddle makes strokes smooth and safe.

  • Grip size

    • If two fingers fit between palm and fingertips when holding, it is close.
    • If you squeeze hard to control, size up with an overgrip.

  • Weight choice

    • Fast hands player: 7.7–7.9 oz, head-light.
    • Baseline hitter or singles: 8.0–8.4 oz for depth and stability.

  • Balance checks

    • If volleys feel late, reduce head weight.
    • If blocks twist, add a little lead at 3 and 9 o’clock.

These small fit wins decide what pickleball paddle should i buy more than any ad.

Try-before-you-buy checklist
Source: lemonpickleball

Try-before-you-buy checklist

A 10-minute test can save you months of doubt.

  • Soft game

    • Dinks clear the net by a ball height without fear.
    • Third-shot drops land in the kitchen more than 7 of 10.

  • Power and depth

    • Serves land deep with your normal swing.
    • Drives do not sail long when you swing hard.

  • Hands speed

    • You can fire three fast volleys without late hits.
    • Blocks stay low and do not twist the grip.

  • Spin

    • You can arc a topspin roll from mid-court with ease.
    • Slices stay low and skid.

If a paddle passes this, it answers what pickleball paddle should i buy with proof, not guesswork.

Common mistakes to avoid
Source: paddlesshop

Common mistakes to avoid

Save money and your arm by dodging these traps.

  • Buying only by brand. Specs and fit matter more.
  • Chasing max power when your control is weak.
  • Ignoring grip size. Hot spots and blisters follow fast.
  • Going too light. Twist and mishits rise.
  • Going too stiff with elbow pain. Pick softer builds first.

Keep these in mind when asking what pickleball paddle should i buy.

Care, tuning, and easy upgrades
Source: paddletek

Care, tuning, and easy upgrades

A few small tweaks can level up any paddle.

  • Overgrips

    • Add 0.5–0.75 size, grip, and sweat control. Cheap and useful.

  • Lead tape

    • Add 2–6 grams at 3 and 9 o’clock for stability.
    • Add a little on the neck to raise swing weight less.

  • Edge and face care

    • Use a gentle eraser to clean carbon texture.
    • Add edge tape if you scrape courts often.

  • Storage and life

    • Do not leave in hot cars. Heat weakens glue and face.
    • Most paddles hold prime play for 6–12 months with steady use.

These steps can turn a good choice into a great answer for what pickleball paddle should i buy right now.

Quick picks by player type
Source: pickleballsuperstore

Quick picks by player type

Use these as starting points. Then fit the grip and weight.

  • New player who wants control

    • 16 mm core, raw carbon face, standard shape, 7.8–8.1 oz.

  • Tennis convert with fast swing

    • 14–16 mm core, elongated shape, mid to high swing weight.

  • Kitchen tactician

    • 16–20 mm core, standard shape, head-light, longer grip optional.

  • Power server and driver

    • Thermoformed, 13–16 mm, elongated, 8.0–8.4 oz.

  • Sore elbow or wrist

    • Soft 16 mm, head-light, smaller grip with cushioned overgrip.

These profiles help lock in what pickleball paddle should i buy without stress.

Real-world notes from the court

Here is what I learned testing dozens of paddles in league play.

  • My mistake

    • I chased a super stiff, high-spin frame. My drops got wild. I lost the net. I switched to a softer 16 mm and my touch came back in a week.

  • A quick win

    • A student kept sailing drives. We moved from fiberglass to raw carbon. Same weight. His topspin bit sooner. Balls dropped in.

  • Arm health tip

    • I had a flare of golfer’s elbow after a heavy week. I swapped to a head-light build and added a thick overgrip. Pain eased in two sessions.

If you wonder what pickleball paddle should i buy for control, start soft. Add power with tape later if needed.

Frequently Asked Questions of what pickleball paddle should i buy

How do I know my ideal grip size?

Wrap your hand and check the two-finger gap. If your fingers barely fit, you are close. Add an overgrip for small adjustments.

Does a heavier paddle always mean more power?

Often yes, but balance matters too. A head-light 8.2 oz can feel softer than a head-heavy 7.9 oz.

Is raw carbon always better than fiberglass?

Not always. Raw carbon gives more spin and dwell. Fiberglass gives easy pop and can help shorter swings.

What should I buy if I have tennis elbow?

Pick a 16 mm soft core, head-light balance, and a cushioned grip. Avoid very stiff thermoformed models at first.

Do I need a USAP-approved paddle?

If you play tournaments or club ladders, yes. For casual play, it is optional but still a good sign of quality.

Conclusion

Pick the paddle that matches your goal, your swing, and your body. Start with control, fit the grip, and test for spin and hands speed. Then add power with shape or a bit of lead if you need it. What pickleball paddle should i buy becomes simple when you follow the specs and your feel.

Ready to choose? Use the checklist above at your local demo day, or try a mail-in demo. Share your short list or questions in the comments, and I will help you dial it in.

Leave a Comment